Are you allowed to plug in your telephone whereas driving in Quebec?

Are you allowed to plug in your telephone whereas driving in Quebec?
Written by admin

A latest court docket ruling provides to the rising checklist of choices that stretch the legislation on the usage of moveable units whereas behind the wheel.

Article content material

Is it doable to make use of a cell phone in the identical means as texting, calling or shopping the net beneath the distracted driving legal guidelines of Quebec?

Promoting 2

Article content material

A latest Quebec court docket ruling discovered that it may not be, including to the rising checklist of choices that stretch the province’s legislation on the usage of moveable units whereas driving.

For legal professional Éric Lamontagne, who makes a speciality of contesting driving infractions, the choice addresses a query that many individuals nonetheless battle with: precisely what are you able to do with a cellphone whereas behind the wheel?

“It is actually a type of (legal guidelines) that individuals have the toughest time understanding how this is applicable,” Lamontane mentioned in an interview. “And that is why selections like these are essential – as a result of they supply a framework for what we are able to and can’t do” whereas driving.

Within the case in query, police officer within the municipality of La Sarre, within the Abitibi-Témiscamingue space, pulled over a driver whereas he was ready at a crimson gentle.

Promoting 3

Article content material

Police mentioned they noticed the person manipulate his telephone whereas the display screen was off. However in a choice made in late June, magistrate Claude Boulianne retained the motive force’s assertion that he was plugging his telephone into his automotive’s USB port, with out ever taking a look at it.

The person was ticketed beneath a provision of Quebec’s Freeway Security Code which stipulates drivers are prohibited from “utilizing” a cell phone whereas driving. The infraction carries a penalty of 5 demerits and a effective of between $ 300 and $ 600.

That is the interpretation of what constitutes “utilizing” a cellphone beneath the legislation that Boulianne wrestled with in his 31-page ruling – a query, he famous, that has been explored in a number of selections since Quebec amended the legislation in 2018.

Promoting 4

Article content material

Boulianne’s determination cites earlier rulings as examples, and famous how the interpretation of what counts as utilizing a cellphone has expanded within the years since.

In 2019, for instance, a choose dominated {that a} Remusky girl checking to see if her telephone was charging was thought of utilizing it. The next yr, alternatively, a choose in St-Jérôme discovered a person selecting their telephone from the ground and placing it away was not counted.

Final yr, a choose dominated a Quebec Metropolis man who held his telephone whereas it was off was not breaking the legislation. Then, per week later, a Montreal municipal court docket choose launched a person who had been arrested whereas selecting up his telephone and placing it in his pocket.

“The jurisprudence has usually very properly established that for a driver to seek the advice of the display screen of their phone or a transportable machine constitutes (utilizing it),” Boulianne wrote. “Due to this fact, to take a look at the time, the climate, a message, the battery stage or every other info is unanimously prohibited.”

Commercial 5

Article content material

Nonetheless, Boulianne added, there stays a “distinction of opinion” when decoding connecting or disconnecting a phone.

Boulianne referred to a latest determination by St-Jérôme by which a choose dominated {that a} phone ought to be inserted to accuse it of a misdemeanor. On this case, the choose agreed to provide an electrical garments iron: as soon as, it’s in use.

However Boulianne lastly dominated in any other case, and determined to launch the motive force in La Sarre.

Though he agreed that connecting a phone might trigger somebody to be momentarily distracted, he famous that the legislation goals to restrict the standard means individuals use cellphones, not all types of distracted driving.

“With respect,” Boulianne added, “the duty of the courts is to interpret the laws, to not search to distort the legislative intent to make it extra coercive.”

Commercial 6

Article content material

For Lamontane, who was not concerned within the case, the choice was the fitting name and exhibits the necessity for the courts to cease clarifying the parameters round cellphone use whereas driving.

Lamontane pointed to a latest case by which a lady used her telephone to pay for a Tim Hortons trip. A police officer occurred to be concurrently within the drive-through, Lamontane mentioned, handing the girl over to make use of her telephone afterwards.

If this isn’t confusion, he added, then he doesn’t know what’s.

“So I imagine that by way of sentences like (Boulianne’s),” Lamontane mentioned, “we have to specify the place the ‘use’ infraction begins and the place it ends.”


PostMedia is dedicated to holding a full of life however well mannered discussion board for dialogue and inspiring all readers to share their opinions on our articles. Feedback might take as much as an hour for moderation earlier than showing on the positioning. We urge you to maintain your suggestions related and respectful. We have now enabled e-mail notifications – you’ll now obtain an e-mail in case you obtain a reply to your remark, it’s an replace to a remark thread that you just comply with or if a consumer you comply with feedback. Go to our Group Pointers for extra info and particulars on learn how to modify your e-mail settings.

About the author


Leave a Comment